Ethanol & Bioenergy News in English

Karnataka High Court refuses interim relief to distillery against curbs on cane juice ethanol

The Karnataka High Court refused interim relief to two distilleries challenging the Centre’s ban on ethanol production from sugarcane juice and B-heavy molasses in ESY 2026-27. Citing sugar shortages, the court allowed applications for legal exemptions and scheduled the next hearing for January 7, 2027.

The Karnataka High Court on November 17, 2026 refused interim relief to Askins Biofuels Private Limited and Shri Bhramanandasagar Jaggery Industries, which had challenged the Centre’s October 22, 2026 order barring ethanol production from sugarcane juice and B-heavy molasses in Ethanol Supply Year (ESY) 2026-27.

In an oral order, Justice C.M. Poonacha held that the petitioners’ commercial activity could not override restrictions issued because of the current sugar shortage. ESY 2026-27 runs from November 1, 2026 to October 31, 2027.

The petitioners asked the court to quash the communication and allow them to keep producing and supplying ethanol, as earlier permitted by Division Bench orders of March 31, 2023 and November 21, 2025. They also sought compensation for loans, losses and expenses that they blamed on what they called an illegal and arbitrary absolute ban.

According to the petition, Askins was set up as a standalone distillery under an Industrial Entrepreneur Memorandum (IEM) dated December 5, 2019, and signed an MoU with Bhramanandasagar, a jaggery maker, to buy cane juice and syrup. The petitioners said the neighbouring Alagawadi Bireshwar Sugars Private Limited had obstructed the plant’s set-up, which led to several rounds of litigation. In those cases, Division Benches held that Askins, as a standalone distillery, fell outside the Sugarcane (Control) Order, 1966 (SCC Order).

The petitioners argued that they used cane only from the 5 per cent of the cane area left to farmers’ discretion, and none from the 95 per cent allotted to sugar factories. They said the ban would halt their production and cause irreparable financial loss to them and their workers, and that it would ruin them commercially. They also cited Hermes Distilleries Pvt Ltd & Others v. Union of India. In that case, they said, the court had first granted interim relief and had recognised the principles of promissory estoppel, legitimate expectation and proportionality.

The Additional Solicitor General, appearing for the respondents, said the curbs were issued under Section 3 of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 and the Sugar (Control) Order, 2025. That order was published in the Gazette on May 1, 2025, and replaced both the Sugar (Control) Order, 1966 and the Sugar Price (Control) Order, 2018. The respondents argued that a sugar scarcity made the ban necessary, because cane diverted to ethanol would reduce sugar supply in the market. They said ethanol from C-heavy molasses was still permitted.

The respondents also said the government had compared the estimated sugar requirement for 2026-27 with net production and taken further steps. These included stock limits on dealers, restrictions on bulk consumers, curbs on mills holding back feedstock and duty-free imports of raw sugar. The respondents described these as interim arrangements, based on a decision by the ministry concerned, until fresh cane estimates become available. They argued that the Hermes Distilleries case had already settled the petitioners’ points, including those raised by standalone distilleries. They added that the ESY 2024-25 order at issue in that case was withdrawn on August 29, 2024.

Separately, Alagawadi applied to join the case as the fifth respondent. The Supreme Court gave it liberty to do so on November 4, 2026, in proceedings where Alagawadi is challenging the Division Bench judgments. Alagawadi contended that Askins and Bhramanandasagar operate from the same place and are not separate entities. The petitioners objected, saying Alagawadi was not a necessary party and that the Supreme Court had not stayed the judgments.

The court observed that the Division Bench rulings concerned closure orders issued by the state government under the SCC Order. Those rulings did not examine the Centre’s powers under the Sugar (Control) Order, 1966. The court noted that the Hermes Distilleries case covered ESY 2024-25, before the 2025 order took effect, and that the main petition in that case was eventually dismissed. It said the petitioners’ claim to be a standalone distillery was disputed.

The court allowed the petitioners to approach the authorities for any permission or relaxation that the law allows. It also allowed both sides to seek changes to the order if circumstances change. The respondents and the petitioners must file their objections within three weeks, and the matter will be heard again on January 7, 2027.

To Read more about Ethanol Industry & Bio Energy News continue reading Agriinsite.com

Source : ChiniMandi

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Latest

To Top